The Paradox of Necessary Delusion: Why Success Requires Ignoring the Odds

The greatest entrepreneurs, artists, athletes, and innovators throughout history share one defining characteristic: they were all magnificently delusional.

They believed they could succeed when every rational metric suggested they would fail.

They pursued impossible dreams while everyone around them cited statistics, probability, and precedent as evidence of their inevitable defeat.

And thank goodness they did.

The Mathematics of Impossible Dreams

Derek Muller’s exploration of egocentric bias in his Veritasium video reveals a startling truth about human psychology and success.

When NASA selected 11 astronauts from over 18,300 applicants in 2017, even if luck accounted for just 5% of the selection process, the simulation showed that only 1.6 of those chosen would have made it based on skill alone.

Nine or ten would have been different candidates entirely if luck played no role.

This isn’t an indictment of their abilities—every astronaut selected was extraordinarily qualified.

But it demonstrates that in highly competitive fields, talent and hard work, while necessary, are insufficient.

You need skill and fortune.

Yet here’s the crucial insight: if those 18,300 applicants had truly understood these odds, how many would have invested the decades of education, training, and sacrifice required to even qualify for consideration?

The answer is terrifyingly few.

And humanity would be poorer for it.

The Birth Lottery and the Compound Effect of Advantage

Consider the hockey players born in January.

Through no merit of their own, they enjoy a massive statistical advantage—being up to four times more likely to reach professional leagues simply because of when they emerged from the womb.

The cutoff date for youth leagues creates a compounding advantage where slightly older, bigger kids get more ice time, better coaching, and enhanced development opportunities that amplify over years.

But here’s what makes this relevant to every dreamer reading this: those future NHL players didn’t know about the January advantage when they first laced up skates.

They believed—delusionally, perhaps—that their dedication and passion would be enough.

Their “delusion” of control drove them to practice relentlessly, to endure countless early morning drives to rinks, to push through failures and setbacks.

The same principle applies to the accident of geography.

Being born in a prosperous country accounts for roughly half the variance in global income.

If you’re reading this article, you likely won the birth lottery in ways that create opportunities unavailable to billions of others.

But acknowledging this luck shouldn’t diminish your drive—it should fuel your responsibility to maximize the advantage you’ve been given.

Why Delusion Fuels Action

There’s a cruel irony embedded in the psychology of achievement: the more accurately you assess your chances of success, the less likely you are to take the actions necessary to succeed.

Muller notes that “if you perceive an outcome to be uncertain, you’re less likely to invest effort in it, which further decreases your chances of success.”

This creates what we might call the “delusion imperative”—the necessity of maintaining unrealistic confidence in your ability to control outcomes in order to invest the effort required to influence them.

It’s a psychological sleight of hand where belief becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Consider the transformative technologies and comforts we enjoy today.

Every breakthrough emerged from someone delusional enough to believe they could solve problems that had stumped countless others.

The Wright brothers ignored the scientific consensus that heavier-than-air flight was impossible.

Steve Jobs believed he could convince consumers they needed a device they didn’t know they wanted.

SpaceX pursued reusable rockets despite decades of failed attempts by better-funded organizations.

The Arena vs. The Stands

Theodore Roosevelt’s famous “Man in the Arena” speech captures this perfectly:

The arena is where delusion becomes essential.

On the sidelines, rational analysis dominates.

You can calculate odds, study failure rates, and construct perfectly logical arguments for why most ventures fail.

But in the arena—where careers are built, companies are launched, and dreams are pursued—delusion provides the fuel for irrational persistence in the face of overwhelming odds.

This explains our fascination with cinematic heroes facing impossible circumstances.

• ​Jon Snow standing alone against a charging army
• ​Leonidas and his 300 Spartans holding Thermopylae
• Neo battling endless Agent Smith

These stories resonate because they represent the triumph of will over probability.

They reflect our deepest understanding that progress requires someone, somewhere, to ignore the math and charge ahead anyway.

The Social Mobility Delusion

Growing up with films like “To Sir, With Love,” “Stand and Deliver,” and “A Million Miles Away” creates something powerful: the delusion that merit and effort can overcome circumstances.

This belief, while statistically naive, becomes psychologically essential for those seeking upward mobility.

​The American Dream itself is a form of mass delusion—the belief that anyone can succeed regardless of their starting point.

The statistics on social mobility suggest this is largely false; most people end up in roughly the same economic class as their parents.

Yet this delusion has driven millions to invest in education, start businesses, and pursue opportunities that occasionally do lead to dramatic life changes.

Without this beneficial delusion, entire generations might resign themselves to predetermined outcomes.

The occasional spectacular success story—the person who does beat the odds—justifies the many who tried and fell short.

Their “failures” still contribute to society through their efforts, innovations, and economic activity.

The Compound Benefits of Delusional Thinking

Delusion serves multiple functions in the psychology of achievement:

1. Energy Conservation - Limited cognitive resources aren’t wasted calculating probabilities of failure. Instead, they’re channeled into problem-solving and opportunity recognition.

2. Resilience Building - Believing in your control over outcomes makes setbacks feel temporary rather than permanent. This extends persistence through inevitable difficulties.

3. Opportunity Creation - Delusional confidence opens doors that realistic assessment would keep closed. People invest in, hire, and partner with those who radiate certainty about their direction.

4. Risk Tolerance - Accurate risk assessment often leads to paralysis. Beneficial delusion enables the calculated risks necessary for significant achievements.

5. Network Effects - Delusional optimism is contagious. It attracts other ambitious people and creates momentum around shared visions.

The Dark Side of Success Delusion

However, this same psychological mechanism creates problematic blindness among those who achieve significant success.

Muller’s research reveals that successful people consistently underestimate the role of luck in their achievements.

This leads to several concerning outcomes:

• Reduced empathy for those less successful, whom they assume must be less talented or hardworking
• Decreased generosity in contributing to the systems that enabled their success
• Policy blindness among leaders who set societal rules without understanding the role of circumstance in outcomes
• Perpetuation of inequality as advantages compound across generations

The cookie experiment Muller describes perfectly illustrates this: when people are randomly assigned leadership roles, they quickly begin feeling entitled to extra rewards, despite having done nothing to earn their position.

The Paradoxical Path Forward

The most sophisticated approach to success requires holding two contradictory beliefs simultaneously:

Believe completely that your success depends entirely on your talent, effort, and decisions. This delusion will drive the persistence, risk-taking, and investment of energy necessary to maximize your potential.

Know intellectually that your outcomes will be heavily influenced by factors beyond your control. This wisdom will make you more grateful, generous, and realistic about others’ circumstances.

This paradox isn’t a bug in human psychology—it’s a feature.

The delusion motivates action while the wisdom prevents hubris. It’s the difference between beneficial self-deception and harmful narcissism.

Practical Applications of Strategic Delusion

For Entrepreneurs: Ignore the 90% failure rate for startups. Believe your idea is the exception. But also build contingency plans and maintain relationships that will catch you if you fall.

For Artists: Create as if your work will change the world. Submit to opportunities despite rejection rates. But also develop skills that provide security during lean periods.

For Career Builders: Apply for positions slightly beyond your qualifications. Negotiate salaries as if you’re irreplaceable. But also acknowledge the mentors and opportunities that opened doors.

For Innovators: Pursue solutions to problems that have stumped experts. Believe your approach will succeed where others failed. But also study those failures to avoid repeating them.

The Responsibility of the Delusional

If you’re fortunate enough to achieve success through this combination of delusion and luck, you inherit a responsibility.

The very systems that enabled your achievement—education, infrastructure, legal frameworks, cultural opportunities—were built by previous generations of successful people who recognized their debt to society.

The cruel irony is that success often blinds us to this debt.

As Muller observes,

Breaking this cycle requires conscious effort to remember and acknowledge the lucky breaks, helpful mentors, and favorable circumstances that contributed to your achievements.

It means using your success to “increase the luck of others,” as Muller puts it.

The Choice: Arena or Stands

Ultimately, this comes down to a fundamental choice about how to live.

You can remain in the stands, armed with accurate statistical analysis about the low probability of extraordinary achievement.

You’ll be right—most people who enter the arena will not achieve their grandest ambitions.

Or you can embrace beneficial delusion, ignore the odds, and charge into the arena.

You’ll probably fall short of your most ambitious goals.

But you’ll also contribute to the great human project of expanding what’s possible, of pushing boundaries, of creating value for others.

The technologies you use, the opportunities you enjoy, the freedoms you exercise—all exist because previous generations chose delusion over realism, action over analysis, the arena over the stands.

The question isn’t whether you’ll succeed in achieving your most ambitious dreams.

The question is whether you’re delusional enough to try—and wise enough to lift others as you climb.

Are you ready to ignore the math and enter the arena?

Or will you retreat to the safety of realistic expectations and join the forgotten masses of history?

The choice, perhaps delusionally, is entirely yours.

P.S. Are you sicked and tired of being surrounded by losers, lemmings and Luddites who are rooted in pragmatic, realistic cowardice?

Then join the Leader's Dojo, where you not only discover how badass you are but you're surrounded by other badass warriors and leaders who will help you to be even better.

​Join now here!​