The Warrior’s Garden: Why Science Proves It’s Better to Be Strong and Kind Than Weak and Hoping

Recently I was watching another Veritasium video about “The Game Theory Problem That Will Change the Way You See the World,” where Derek Muller explores the fascinating science behind the Prisoner’s Dilemma and its implications for human cooperation.

What struck me most wasn’t just the mathematical elegance of the research, but how it provides scientific validation for an ancient piece of wisdom: it’s better to be a warrior in a garden than a gardener in a war.

The video details Robert Axelrod’s famous computer tournament from 1980, where game theorists submitted algorithms to compete in repeated Prisoner’s Dilemma scenarios. The results were revolutionary and counter-intuitive: assholes and pushovers both lose, while warriors who are nice, forgiving, retaliatory, and maintain clear boundaries win over the long run.

You don’t need to be a dick to get ahead, and you can forgive someone for being a dick, but within certain limits.

The key to success, happiness, and getting along over the long haul is clearly communicating boundaries and making transgressors pay with appropriate consequences.

The Mathematical Foundation of Strength and Kindness

The Prisoner’s Dilemma reveals something profound about the nature of cooperation and competition.

In the classic setup, two players can either cooperate or defect:

• If both cooperate, both get a moderate reward
• If one cooperates and the other defects, the defector gets a large reward while the cooperator gets nothing
• If both defect, both get a small punishment

The genius of Axelrod’s tournament was testing these dynamics over repeated interactions—essentially modeling long-term relationships rather than one-time encounters.

The winning strategy, called “Tit for Tat,” embodied four crucial characteristics that perfectly mirror the warrior-in-garden philosophy:

1. Nice (Never defect first)
2. Retaliatory (Punish defection immediately)
3. Forgiving (Return to cooperation after retaliation)
4. Clear (Predictable and easy to understand)

This isn’t just academic theory—it’s a mathematical proof that controlled strength combined with selective kindness creates optimal long-term outcomes.

Working with Coworkers in Construction

Working construction for decades provided me with countless real-world examples of these game theory principles in action.

The “Always Cooperate” Workers were the pushovers who never stood up for themselves. They’d work overtime damaging relationships at home, accept blame for others’ mistakes, and allow crew members to take advantage of their good nature. While initially popular, they eventually lost respect and found themselves stuck in the worst positions with the heaviest workloads.

The “Always Defect” Workers were the assholes who tried to maximize their own benefit at everyone else’s expense. They’d steal tools, blame others for their mistakes, and avoid helping teammates. While they might gain short-term advantages, they quickly found themselves isolated, untrusted, and eventually fired or frozen out of good opportunities.

The “Tit for Tat” Workers were the ones who succeeded long-term. They were helpful and cooperative by default, but they retaliated quickly and proportionally when someone tried to take advantage. They’d help a struggling teammate but wouldn’t cover for chronic slackers. They’d share tools but remember who didn’t reciprocate. They’d work hard but demand fair compensation.

This was how I and other workers became crew leaders, foremen, and successful contractors because they created environments where cooperation flourished while preventing exploitation.

Martial Arts and the Game of Life

Martial arts is a great metaphor for the warrior-in-garden philosophy.

On the mats, you encounter both strength and gentleness in their purest forms.

The warrior aspect is obvious: you’re learning to defend yourself, to apply force when necessary, to remain calm under pressure, and to overcome opponents who are actively trying to dominate you. You develop physical and mental toughness that translates to every area of life.

The garden aspect is equally important: you’re cultivating patience, technique, respect for training partners, and the wisdom to know when force is appropriate and when it isn’t. You learn to be gentle with beginners while defending yourself against advanced practitioners.

The most successful martial artists embody both qualities simultaneously. They can submit opponents decisively when necessary, but they do so with control and respect. They help newer students learn while defending themselves against anyone who tries to take advantage.

This combination creates the optimal training environment: safe enough for growth, challenging enough for development, and respectful enough for long-term relationships.

The Neuroscience of Boundaries

Modern neuroscience supports what game theory mathematics revealed: clear boundaries combined with selective cooperation create optimal outcomes for all parties involved.

When boundaries are unclear or inconsistently enforced, people experience chronic stress because they can’t predict the consequences of their actions.

This creates anxiety, reduces trust, and leads to suboptimal decision-making.

When boundaries are clear and consistently enforced, several positive things happen:

Reduced Cognitive Load - People don’t have to constantly guess what’s acceptable, freeing mental energy for productive activities.

Increased Trust - Predictable consequences create psychological safety and allow deeper cooperation.

Better Decision-Making - Clear cause-and-effect relationships enable people to make informed choices about their behavior.

Enhanced Learning - Immediate, proportional feedback accelerates behavioral adaptation and skill development.

Improved Relationships - Mutual respect develops when everyone knows and respects the rules of engagement.

The Evolutionary Advantage

From an evolutionary perspective, the warrior-in-garden strategy represents the optimal survival approach.

Humans who were purely aggressive didn’t form the cooperative alliances necessary for complex social living.

Humans who were purely passive became victims and didn’t pass on their genes.

The humans who survived and thrived were those who could cooperate when cooperation was beneficial and retaliate when cooperation was exploited.

This created what evolutionary biologists call “reciprocal altruism”—the foundation of human civilization.

We help others with the expectation that they’ll help us in return, but we punish those who violate this social contract.

The warrior-in-garden approach is literally encoded in our DNA as the optimal strategy for long-term success and species survival.

How This Applies in Business

In business contexts, this principle manifests as what researchers call “principled negotiation” or “enlightened self-interest.”

Successful business leaders tend to be generous with win-win opportunities, quick to address violations of agreements, forgiving of honest mistakes, and crystal clear about their expectations and boundaries.

They create environments where ethical behavior is rewarded and unethical behavior has immediate, proportional consequences.

This approach builds long-term relationships, attracts high-quality partners and employees, and creates sustainable competitive advantages.

Companies that operate on pure aggression (always defect) eventually face legal challenges, talent exodus, and reputation damage that destroys long-term value.

Companies that operate with no boundaries (always cooperate) get taken advantage of by competitors, customers, and even employees, leading to unsustainable business models.

The Parenting Parallel of the Way of the Warrior

The warrior-in-garden philosophy provides an excellent framework for effective parenting.

Children need both security and structure, both love and limits.

The “garden” aspects include unconditional love, emotional support, encouragement of growth, and creating safe spaces for learning and development.

The “warrior” aspects include setting clear boundaries, enforcing consequences consistently, teaching children to defend themselves, and modeling strength in difficult situations.

Children raised with this approach tend to develop healthy self-esteem, strong moral boundaries, resilience in face of challenges, and the ability to form healthy relationships throughout their lives.

Children raised with only kindness often struggle with boundaries, become victims of bullying, and have difficulty standing up for themselves in adult relationships.

Children raised with only strictness often develop anxiety, rebellion, or inability to form trusting relationships with others.

The Relationship Dynamics of Reciprocation

In personal relationships, the warrior-in-garden approach creates the foundation for both intimacy and respect.

The garden qualities foster emotional connection: vulnerability, empathy, support during difficult times, celebration of successes, and the willingness to forgive and grow together.

The warrior qualities maintain healthy relationship dynamics: clear communication about needs and boundaries, willingness to address problems directly, refusal to enable destructive behavior, and the strength to end relationships that become toxic.

Relationships built on this foundation tend to be both passionate and stable, both supportive and challenging, both intimate and respectful.

People who are only “nice” often find themselves in relationships where they’re taken for granted, manipulated, or treated with disrespect.

People who are only “strong” often find themselves in relationships that lack emotional depth, trust, and genuine intimacy.

The Leadership Paradox of Carrots and Sticks

Great leaders embody the warrior-in-garden paradox perfectly.

They must be simultaneously strong enough to make difficult decisions and kind enough to inspire loyalty and cooperation.

The most effective leaders are those who create psychologically safe environments where people can take risks and make mistakes, while also maintaining high standards and clear accountability.

They celebrate successes generously but address failures directly. They support team members’ growth while demanding excellence. They forgive honest mistakes while refusing to tolerate intentional misconduct.

This combination creates high-performance cultures where people are motivated to excel, secure enough to innovate, and confident that fairness will prevail.

The Daily Implementation Framework

Week 1: Boundary Assessment

• Identify areas where you’ve been too nice (allowing exploitation)
• Identify areas where you’ve been too harsh (damaging relationships)
• Notice situations where unclear boundaries create confusion or conflict
• Observe the long-term consequences of your current approach

Week 2: Clear Communication

• Practice stating your boundaries clearly and kindly
• Develop scripts for addressing boundary violations
• Work on being more generous with genuine cooperation
• Focus on being predictable and consistent in your responses

Week 3: Proportional Response

• Practice responding to cooperation with increased cooperation
• Practice responding to violations with appropriate consequences
• Work on forgiving quickly after appropriate retaliation
• Focus on clarity about what behaviors you will and won’t accept

Week 4: Long-term Integration

• Notice how people respond to your clearer boundaries
• Observe improvements in relationship quality and mutual respect
• Adjust your approach based on feedback and results
• Celebrate progress in both strength and kindness

The Scientific Validation

What makes this approach so powerful is that it’s not just philosophical wisdom—it’s scientifically validated strategy backed by mathematics, evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and decades of social science research.

​Game theory proves that Tit for Tat strategies outperform both purely aggressive and purely passive approaches in repeated interactions.

Evolutionary biology shows that reciprocal altruism is the foundation of human cooperation and civilization.

Neuroscience demonstrates that clear, consistent boundaries reduce stress and improve decision-making for everyone involved.

Social psychology confirms that relationships built on mutual respect and clear expectations are more satisfying and durable than those based purely on niceness or dominance.

The Compound Effect

The warrior-in-garden approach creates compound benefits over time:

Better Relationships - People respect you more because they know where they stand and that you’ll treat them fairly.

Increased Influence - Your word carries more weight because people know you mean what you say and will follow through.

Reduced Stress - Clear boundaries eliminate much of the anxiety and conflict that comes from unclear expectations.

Greater Success - You attract better opportunities and partners because you’ve demonstrated both competence and character.

Enhanced Self-Respect - You maintain your integrity while building meaningful connections with others.

Putting It On the Mat and In Life

The ancient wisdom of being “a warrior in a garden rather than a gardener in a war” isn’t just poetic philosophy—it’s mathematically proven optimal strategy for long-term success and happiness.

Derek Muller’s exploration of the Prisoner’s Dilemma reveals that the most successful approach combines strength with kindness, retaliation with forgiveness, and clear boundaries with generous cooperation.

You don’t need to be a dick to get ahead in life.

In fact, being a dick is mathematically proven to be a losing strategy over time.

But you also can’t be a pushover who allows others to take advantage of your good nature.

The optimal approach is to be nice by default, quick to retaliate when someone violates your boundaries, willing to forgive when they return to cooperation, and crystal clear about what you will and won’t accept.

This creates environments where cooperation flourishes while preventing exploitation.

It builds relationships based on mutual respect rather than fear or resentment.

It attracts high-quality people while repelling those who would take advantage.

In a world full of assholes and pushovers, the warrior-gardeners inherit the earth.

They create the gardens where cooperation can flourish, but they have the warrior skills to defend those gardens when necessary.

They offer kindness freely but demand respect in return.

They forgive readily but never forget the lessons.

Science has proven what warriors have always known: true strength comes not from the ability to destroy, but from the wisdom to know when strength is necessary and when gentleness will serve better.

• Cultivate your garden with warrior’s strength.
• Tend your relationships with a gardener’s patience.
• Set boundaries with a warrior’s clarity.
• Offer cooperation with a gardener’s generosity.

The math is clear, the science is settled, and the results speak for themselves.

Be a warrior in a garden.

The world needs more of them.

Are you sicked and tired of being surrounded by losers, lemmings and Luddites and want to join other warriors, leaders and badasses?

Then join the Leader's Dojo, where you not only discover how badass you are but you're surrounded by other badass warriors and leaders who will help you to be even better.

​Join now here!​