Social Proof: Why Following the Crowd Holds You Back


Just Because Everybody’s Doing It Doesn’t Mean You Should

If you want to be better than average, be careful whom you choose to follow.

Have you ever looked around at what everybody else was doing and wondered whether you should be doing the same thing?

Maybe everyone at work seems content doing just enough to get by. Maybe your friends are spending money they don’t have. Maybe your whole industry follows a practice nobody bothers to question.

There’s a natural temptation to go along.

After all, if everybody else is doing it, how wrong can it be?

But here’s a question worth sitting with.

What if you don’t want the results everybody else is getting?

I’ve spent much of my life watching people, trying to understand why some become exceptionally good at what they do while others struggle or just get by.

And one thing has become clear.

If you want to become exceptionally good at something, you have to be choosy about whom you learn from.

I think that lesson started forming when I was a teenager, standing in a Los Angeles museum, mesmerized by thousands of little balls falling through a maze of pegs.

The Bookworm Who Watched People

Growing up, I was an introvert and a bookworm.

I spent a lot of time reading, studying, and chasing whatever caught my curiosity.

Part of that was just my personality. And part of it was that I didn’t really understand people.

Why did they do some of the things they did? Why did they follow leaders who didn’t seem to know where they were going? Why did belonging to a group sometimes matter more than whether the group was doing anything worthwhile?

I didn’t have everything figured out. Far from it.

But because I often kept to myself, I spent a lot of time observing.

Watching how people behaved. Noticing what they did. And eventually noticing the differences in the results they produced.

Have you ever stood outside a group and watched everyone follow along with something that didn’t make sense to you?

Being an outsider gave me a little distance. I could watch before deciding whether something was worth joining.

And that habit became useful when I entered the working world.

But first, there was that museum.

Thousands of Little Balls

In 1976, and again in 1980, my sister and I spent extended summer holidays in Los Angeles, staying with our aunt and cousin. My mother joined us for parts of those trips, including the road trips and camping.

For a kid growing up in Honolulu, Los Angeles was thrilling.

I especially loved the museums. Exhibits about prehistoric humans, fossils, and what life might have looked like thousands of years ago.

I could spend hours in those places.

But the exhibit I remember most wasn’t a dinosaur or an ancient artifact.

It was a machine dropping little balls through a series of pegs.

You’ve probably seen something similar. It’s commonly called a Galton board.

The balls fall from the top, bounce left or right off the pegs, and settle into compartments along the bottom.

And something fascinating happens.

Most of the balls collect near the middle. Fewer land toward either edge.

As more balls fall, a familiar bell-shaped pattern emerges.

Then the machine resets.

And the pattern appears again.

I was mesmerized.

Each ball followed its own unpredictable path. But together, they formed a remarkably consistent shape.

I didn’t understand the mathematics behind it. What caught me was the pattern.

The middle held the biggest group. The edges held far fewer.

That picture stayed with me long after I left the museum.

Years later, when I learned about the 80/20 rule, I connected that bell-shaped picture to something I kept observing in real life.

The 20/60/20 Picture I Carry in My Head

The Pareto principle, commonly called the 80/20 rule, and a bell curve are two different mathematical ideas.

But in my own head, they’ve become connected.

I use a simple 20/60/20 picture when thinking about performance.

On one side, I imagine roughly 20% of people making things happen. They’re learning, taking ownership, solving problems, and producing exceptional results.

In the middle, I picture 60% generally doing their best, meeting their responsibilities, and getting by.

And on the other side, 20% whose habits or performance create problems or slow things down.

These aren’t scientifically verified percentages for every workplace. They’re my personal model for thinking about differences in performance.

But here’s the important part.

I’m interested in the right-hand edge of that picture.

The people making things happen.

Because that’s where I want to be.

I’m not interested in spending my life complaining about people who aren’t performing. And there’s nothing wrong with wanting a steady job, a paycheck, and a life outside work.

But when I decide I want to get good at something, I don’t want to settle for copying whatever happens to be common.

I want to learn from the people who are exceptionally good at it.

That became unmistakable at my first job after high school.

Welcome to the Adult World

From around 1983 until I moved to Los Angeles in 1986, I worked at Orson’s Restaurant.

That was my first real exposure to an adult working environment.

And I’ll tell you something.

The adult world wasn’t nearly as mature as I’d imagined.

I’d assumed adults knew what they were doing. They had jobs, responsibilities, and some idea of how life worked.

That assumption didn’t survive long.

At Orson’s, we had waiters, waitresses, bussers.

Our specific duties varied, but we shared the same basic responsibility.

Take care of the restaurant. Take care of the customers. Handle your shit.

That was the job.

And what fascinated me was how differently people could perform under essentially the same conditions.

It didn’t matter to me whether someone was male or female, or what their background was.

Could they do the job?

And how well?

Some of those waiters and waitresses were absolute badasses.

They knew how to take care of customers, keep things moving, and make people feel welcome.

They understood that good service wasn’t just delivering food to a table. It was creating an experience.

I watched those people.

I learned from them.

And when I did my job well, helping them take care of their customers, some would slip me extra tips on the side.

Why?

Because I was helping them succeed.

A good busboy made their jobs easier, their customers happier, and their service better.

We all won.

Then there were others who seemed content just getting through their shifts.

And some who were simply bad at the job. The worst generally didn’t last long.

Others stayed employed but complained about their customers, their tips, and how little money they made.

I’d look at the people doing exceptionally well and think:

Why not learn from them?

Want better tips? Learn how to provide better service.

Want to become a better busboy? Watch the people who make the restaurant run smoothly.

Want to be a better waiter or waitress? Pay attention to the people customers love being served by.

Now, tips aren’t a perfect measure of skill. Customer generosity, shift assignments, table sections, and plain luck all matter.

But I could see the differences in service quality with my own eyes.

And I could see how the best workers made everybody around them more effective.

Have you ever worked beside somebody with the same basic responsibilities as you, but noticeably better results?

What were they doing differently?

That became the question I learned to ask.

Not why somebody else wasn’t performing.

What could I learn from the people who were?

The Union Promise: A Competent Journeyman

I moved to Los Angeles in 1986 and entered construction that November as a fire alarm technician.

Talk about an education.

The scale of the jobs, the equipment, the personalities, the expectations—at first, it was overwhelming.

After about a year and a half as a technician, I entered my four-year electrical apprenticeship.

And I started seeing the same patterns I’d noticed at Orson’s.

One of the great strengths of a union apprenticeship is that it establishes a common standard of training.

When someone completes the program and becomes a journeyman electrician, they’re expected to have the core competence necessary to perform the trade.

That’s part of what the union offers contractors.

A trained workforce. Qualified journeymen who can be dispatched to different jobs and perform the work.

Within the requirements of our classification and qualifications, we’re supposed to be interchangeable.

And that’s valuable.

But here’s what I learned.

A common qualification doesn’t mean everyone performs at the same level.

Put several journeymen on a project, all with the same classification and pay scale, and you’d see real differences in how they approached the work.

Some took ownership.

They anticipated problems, knew their tools and materials, and understood how their piece fit into the larger job.

They looked ahead, organized the work, and got things done.

Others performed their assigned tasks competently but had little interest in taking on anything additional.

And some created problems somebody else had to clean up.

That familiar pattern again.

But what fascinated me wasn’t the bottom or the middle.

It was the top.

What made those workers different? And what could I learn from them?

The Apprentices Who Were Already Leading

I remember a couple of guys in my apprenticeship class who were already functioning like foremen while they were still apprentices.

They had previous experience.

They understood the work.

And they owned their responsibilities.

They weren’t waiting for somebody to hand them a title before taking responsibility.

They were already demonstrating leadership through the way they worked.

Soon after becoming journeymen, they moved into foreman positions formally.

Those guys caught my attention.

Here we were, going through the same apprenticeship program, working toward the same journeyman classification.

But they were operating at a different level.

I wanted to understand why.

How did they approach problems? How did they organize work? How did they think ahead?

What did they know that I didn’t?

My own path was different.

I didn’t rush into becoming a foreman, partly because I didn’t particularly want the job.

I enjoyed doing the electrical work. I wasn’t eager to deal with everyone’s people problems.

And I didn’t have much mentorship showing me how to move into leadership.

But that didn’t stop me from learning from the guys who were already doing it well.

They showed me what was possible.

And they demonstrated that meeting a professional standard and becoming exceptional at your work were two different things.

The standard is a foundation. What you build on top of it is another matter.

Social Proof: When Normal Isn’t Good Enough

In Robert Cialdini’s Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, he explores a principle called social proof.

When we’re unsure what to do, we often look at what other people are doing.

And that makes sense.

Imagine you’re visiting an unfamiliar city.

You’re hungry, and there are two restaurants side by side.

One has a line out the door.

The other is nearly empty.

Which catches your attention?

Probably the busy one.

You assume all those customers must know something.

Maybe the food is better. Maybe the service is excellent. Maybe it’s simply fashionable.

Social proof can be useful.

We can’t investigate every decision from scratch, and other people’s behavior sometimes gives us valuable information.

But here’s where people get tangled up.

They confuse what’s common with what’s excellent.

Those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

At Orson’s, if I’d simply copied whatever most people were doing, would I have learned to provide exceptional service?

As a journeyman electrician, if I’d copied the habits of the average worker, would that have helped me become exceptionally competent?

And if I’d wanted to lead, would following people with no interest in leadership have taught me how?

Probably not.

The crowd could show me what was normal.

But normal wasn’t the standard I was aiming for.

That’s why my bell-curve picture has stayed useful.

I wanted to study the people I thought of as the top 20%.

Not because those people were worth more as human beings.

Because they were demonstrating a level of performance I wanted to reach.

Equal Standards Don’t Produce Equal Results

A fair system can give people equal standing, common standards, or comparable opportunities.

Those are valuable things.

But they don’t guarantee identical results.

At Orson’s, people working similar jobs demonstrated different levels of service.

In construction, journeymen holding the same classification showed different levels of initiative, judgment, and productivity.

The system established expectations.

Individuals still differed in how they performed.

Of course, mentorship, opportunities, experience, and circumstances all influence outcomes.

But so do preparation, practice, responsibility, and the choices we make.

Think about your own life.

Maybe you and your coworkers hold the same job title.

Maybe you and your classmates are enrolled in the same program.

Maybe you and your training partners attend the same martial arts classes.

Does that mean you’ll all develop identical abilities?

Of course not.

What you practice, how you learn, and what you pay attention to all matter.

And when you’re trying to improve, it makes sense to study people who demonstrate the qualities you’re trying to develop.

But there’s another trap.

Don’t blindly copy the best performers, either.

A great electrician might be terrible with money.

An exceptional martial artist might struggle with relationships.

Someone outstanding in one area can be ordinary—or worse—in another.

So be specific.

What are they actually good at?

What evidence do you have?

What can you learn from them?

And what should you leave behind?

Study their excellence without assuming they’re excellent at everything.

Choose Your Own Standard

When I think back to that museum exhibit, I still picture those little balls falling through the pegs.

The big cluster in the middle.

The smaller groups toward the edges.

That picture became part of how I think about performance.

And when I later learned about the 80/20 rule, it reinforced my habit of looking for the relatively few people whose actions were producing exceptional results.

I’m not interested in criticizing the majority for having different goals.

But when I decide something matters to me, I want to become good at it.

Really good.

That means learning from people who’ve demonstrated the competence, judgment, and discipline I want to develop.

Not automatically following whatever everybody else happens to be doing.

Because the people around you quietly influence what you consider normal.

Your coworkers. Friends. Teachers. Family. The people you watch online.

Their habits can become your habits before you even think to question them.

And if those habits aren’t taking you where you want to go, you can spend years following a path that was never really yours.

That’s the lesson I want to close our week on Influence with.

We’ve explored authority, reciprocity, liking, commitment, scarcity, unity, and social proof.

None of those influences are automatically bad.

We learn from one another.

We depend on one another.

But we should be deliberate about which examples we choose to follow.

The goal isn’t to reject the crowd just because it’s a crowd.

Sometimes the majority is doing something because it genuinely works.

But if you want to become exceptional at something, you need to know what exceptional actually looks like.

Then study it.

Practice it.

Test it.

And make it your own.

Because social proof can tell you what everybody else is doing.

It can’t tell you what standard to hold yourself to.

⚔️ The Daily Dojo Drill

Pick one area of your life where you want to get better.

Your work, fitness, finances, relationships, or ability to lead.

Then ask yourself three questions.

1. Who do I know who is genuinely excellent at this?

Not necessarily the most popular, the loudest, or the one with the fanciest title.

Who consistently demonstrates the results and qualities I admire?

2. What are they doing differently?

Look at their habits, preparation, judgment, how they handle setbacks, and how they take responsibility.

3. What’s one thing I can learn from them and start practicing myself?

You don’t have to copy their whole life.

And you don’t have to reject everyone else just to be different.

But you do need to choose your models deliberately.

Because if you want to become better than you are today, it makes sense to learn from people already demonstrating what better looks like.

Just because everybody’s doing it doesn’t mean you should.

And just because only a few people are doing something doesn’t mean you can’t become one of them.

📚 From the Leader’s Library

​Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion — Robert Cialdini​

Why?

What if some of the decisions you believe you’re making freely are being influenced by things you don’t even notice?

In Influence, Robert Cialdini explores the psychological principles that shape why people say yes, whom they trust, and how they make decisions—sometimes without consciously recognizing what’s influencing them.

I’m not recommending this book so you can learn to manipulate people.

I’m recommending it so you can recognize when someone might be manipulating you.

Whether it’s advertising, sales, social media, politics, or everyday relationships, understanding what motivates people helps you recognize the invisible pressures behind your decisions.

And it can help you communicate more effectively, honestly, and respectfully with others.

The goal isn’t to become better at controlling people. It’s to become harder to manipulate—and more deliberate about the choices you make.

Charles Doublet

Helping young men to become warriors, leaders, and teachers. Showing them how to overcome fear, bullies, and life's challenges so they can live the life they were meant to live, for more, check out https://CharlesDoublet.com/

Read more from Charles Doublet
An illustration of a couple talking with a friendly merchant over hibiscus tea in a Cairo spice shop.

When Is Enough Enough? Knowing when to stop reaching isn’t the same as giving up. Have you ever gotten such a good deal that you walked away feeling like you’d actually won? Maybe you talked someone down on a price. Maybe you negotiated a higher salary. Maybe you bought something you didn’t even need because the discount felt too good to pass up. Here’s a question worth lingering on. If you get everything you want, but the person across from you walks away unhappy, did you really win? I’ve...

A martial artist in a black gi overlooks mountains at sunrise beside wooden signs naming the seven principles of influence.

7 Ways to Stop Being Manipulated and Start Leading Yourself The forces shaping your decisions are often the ones you never stop to question. Have you ever said yes to something you really didn’t want to do? Maybe someone did you a favor, and you felt obligated to return it. Maybe you’d made a commitment and didn’t want to look unreliable. Or maybe you simply liked the person asking. What was really driving your decision? We like to believe we’re independent thinkers. But every day, people,...

Editorial illustration featuring a 100-box daily planner, a phone displaying urgent alerts, Napoleon beside stacked letters, Eisenhower, and Chicken Little on a breaking-news screen.

The World Is Ending. Again. Check Back in 15 Minutes. What Napoleon, Eisenhower, and 100 little boxes can teach us about urgency, scarcity, and protecting our attention. How many emergencies have you had today? Seriously. How many times has your phone buzzed, beeped, or flashed for your attention? How many emails arrived marked URGENT? How many headlines warned you about the latest crisis? And how many of those were actual emergencies? Not somebody else’s impatience, not a marketing campaign,...