The Question Every Person on My Crew Was Asking


The Question Every Person on My Crew Was Asking

How studying marketing taught me to become a better foreman, and made it easier to keep good people or let the wrong fit go.

I didn’t study marketing to become a better foreman.

I was trying to help my wife, Amy build her somatic therapy business. So I started learning the business side of things, the part nobody hands you along with your tools when you get good at your trade.

Then I ran across five letters that changed the way I dealt with people.

WIIFM.

What’s In It For Me?

It sounds selfish, doesn’t it?

But the more I sat with it, the more I realized everybody walks around asking some version of that question. Not always out loud. Not always consciously. And not always about money.

Sometimes the answer is safety. Sometimes it’s respect. Sometimes it’s belonging. Sometimes it’s the straight satisfaction of doing good work, or knowing you helped somebody.

I grew up in Hawaii, where ohana — family, connection, looking out for one another — was part of how I understood the world from the start.

I’ll help someone because it feels good to help. That doesn’t mean I’m waiting for them to become a customer, return the favor, or save up a debt.

There’s a maxim I try to keep close:

If you’re giving a gift and expecting a gift in return, it’s not a gift.
It’s a bribe.

That doesn’t mean generosity never comes back around. It often does. When I’ve needed help and asked for it, people have stepped up for me, and I try to be that person for them.

That’s reciprocity, one of Robert Cialdini’s principles in Influence.

But there’s a difference between a relationship built on genuine care and one built on an invisible ledger of debts, where somebody is quietly keeping score.

And WIIFM taught me something else, something more immediately useful on a jobsite.

If I wanted a good crew, I couldn’t think only about what I needed from the people working for me.

I needed them to know I was thinking about what mattered to them, too.

That might sound obvious.

But if you’ve spent much time working in construction, you know it wasn’t always how things worked.

I worked with plenty of foremen who treated their workers as disposable.

There was an ugly saying in construction:

“Step on one, watch the rest run.”

That was the mentality. Intimidate one worker, and the others would fall in line.

I didn’t want to be that kind of foreman.

I wanted the people on my crew to know that I saw them as human beings, not just another pair of hands with a tool belt.

And I wanted to establish that from the beginning, before we had problems, disagreements, or difficult decisions to make.

So I developed my spiel, a little speech.

My three assumptions and three asks.

It became something I shared with every person who joined my crew, and it saved me an enormous amount of grief.

Before I Told Them What I Wanted, I Showed Them I Was Thinking About Them

When somebody joined my crew, I didn’t start with a long lecture about everything I expected.

I started with three assumptions.

Not because I needed to interrogate them about their motivations.

I was pretty sure I already understood the basics.

I wanted them to hear me acknowledge those things out loud.

I wanted them to know that their interests were part of my thinking.

Assumption 1: You’re Here to Make Money

I’d say something along these lines:

“I assume you’re here because you want to make money.
You’re not here for shits and giggles, a hobby, or because you’ve got nothing else going on in your life.
You’re here to make your money, right?”

Of course they were.

They had families, bills, ambitions, and real reasons to be standing there.

They weren’t there out of devotion to me or the project.

And I wasn’t going to pretend otherwise.

Assumption 2: You Want to Go Home in One Piece

Then I’d keep going:

“I assume while you’re working here, you want to go home in one piece.
Not in an ambulance or a hearse, right?”

That’s not a cute management slogan.

Construction can hurt people.

Bad decisions have consequences that follow somebody home, if they’re lucky enough to get home at all.

Safety wasn’t something I was doing for the company while the workers were expected to take all the risks.

It was something the people working for me had every right to expect.

And I wanted them to know I understood that.

Assumption 3: You Don’t Want to Be Fucked With

And then the last one:

“I assume while you’re working here, you don’t want to be fucked with.
You want to be left alone to do your job.
No drama, no bullshit, no bullying.
Right?”

We’d get agreement on that too.

And I wanted the same thing.

Show up, do good work, be treated like a grown adult, and don’t have somebody making your day miserable for no good reason.

That included me.

I wasn’t interested in being the foreman who pushed people around just because I had the authority to do it.

You see what I was doing there.

Before asking them to do anything for me, I was showing them that I was thinking about what they wanted out of the working relationship.

Money.

Safety.

A decent place to work.

I wanted them to know their WIIFM mattered to me.

And once we’d established that, I could explain what I needed from them.

“Good. Now I Have Three Asks.”

Once we’d agreed on the three assumptions, I’d say:

“Good. Then I have three asks.”

And I’d lay them out just as plainly.

Ask 1: Own Your Work

“If you’re given a project, take it on and own it.
Do it to the best of your ability.
Don’t knowingly leave loose ends for somebody else to come along and pick up behind you.”

That didn’t mean nobody could make a mistake. People are human. Apprentices are learning. Everybody needs help sometimes.

It meant don’t knowingly hand your problems to the next person because you couldn’t be bothered to finish what was yours.

If you needed something, communicate it. If you saw a problem, raise it. If you screwed up, own it and help make it right.

Ask 2: Don’t Make Your Coworkers’ Jobs Harder

“Get your own tools, materials, and whatever else you need.
Don’t take up somebody else’s time taking their stuff, or standing around talking about things that have nothing to do with the work.”

I wasn’t against small talk. We joked around and gave each other hell like any crew.

But there’s a difference between being friendly and regularly disrupting somebody who’s trying to get a job done.

The same respect you wanted from your coworkers was respect you owed back to them.

Ask 3: Know What Your Real Job Is

Here’s where I set the hook.

“Finally, do you know what your job is?”

Usually the person would give me an answer about being an electrician, or an apprentice, or the tasks that came with the title.

And I’d tell them:

“You’re not wrong. But that’s only part of it.”

Then I’d give them the answer.

“Your job is to make your immediate supervisor’s job easier.”

If they were an apprentice, that meant helping their journeyman get the work done.

If they were a journeyman, I’d point at myself.

“That means if you make my job easier, I want you around.
If you make my job harder, I don’t care how badass your installations are.
You’re still making my life and my job harder.
I don’t need that.
Get it?”

That was the third ask.

Not “kiss my ass.” Not “agree with everything I say.” And certainly not “keep your mouth shut when you see something unsafe.”

I wanted people who could work, think, communicate, solve problems, and help the whole crew succeed.

And I owed them the same in return.

Then My Journeyman Told Me My Name Was Tim

One of the best lessons I learned about that third ask came from a journeyman I respected.

We’d worked together before.

He was a good worker, someone I knew I could depend on.

In fact, when I became the foreman on another project, he was one of the people I specifically requested for my crew.

One day, he told me something that caught me off guard.

“Your name is Tim.”

I asked him what he meant.

We already knew each other. We’d worked together before. And he certainly knew my name wasn’t Tim.

He explained.

“Not Tim. T.I.M.”

Tools. Information. Material.

That was what he needed from me.

He was the journeyman. I was the foreman.

He needed the right tools.

He needed the information to understand the work and plan his installation.

And he needed the materials to get it done.

That was my job.

Think about that for a second.

Here I was, the foreman, responsible for directing the work. And one of the guys I’d specifically requested because I knew he was a good worker was reminding me what he needed from me to do his job.

Without those three things, how was he supposed to deliver the results I expected?

I could demand that he take ownership of his work.

I could insist he work efficiently.

I could tell him his job was to make my job easier.

But if I wasn’t holding up my end, if I wasn’t making sure he had what he needed, then I was the one making his job harder.

That landed on me and stayed.

Because it reinforced something essential about my third ask.

It worked both ways.

If I wanted my apprentices and journeymen to make their supervisors’ jobs easier, then I had to make it possible for them to succeed first.

I had to be their T.I.M.

Tools. Information. Material.

That was my responsibility.

Their job was to use those resources, take ownership, communicate problems, and give their best effort.

My job was to make their best effort realistic.

That’s how I supported them to support me.

Not a one-way command.

A working agreement that traveled both directions up and down the chain.

And suddenly WIIFM got a lot more interesting.

Because it wasn’t just about what I wanted from them.

It was about recognizing what each of us needed, and finding a way for all of us to succeed by doing our part for one another.

The Agreement Made Hard Conversations Easier

There’s a big difference between telling somebody they’re a problem, and talking together about an agreement you both already made.

When someone started making my job harder, or making things harder for the people around them, I didn’t have to open with an attack on their character.

I could go back to that first conversation.

“Remember our three assumptions and three asks? Which part are we having trouble with?”

Then I’d ask them to help me figure out the fix.

This brings in the Consistency & Commitment principles from Cialdini

Maybe they didn’t understand what I needed. Maybe I’d failed to give clear direction. Maybe there was a problem on the job I hadn’t seen. Maybe I hadn’t provided the tools, information, or materials.

Or maybe they weren’t holding up their end.

That’s a genuinely important distinction to get right.

If the problem was on my side of the agreement, I needed to fix my side. If it was on theirs, we could talk about what had to change.

The point was to make the person part of finding the solution, instead of turning the whole thing into a fight before either of us had actually looked at it.

Not every problem got solved. Sometimes we couldn’t reach a way forward that worked for both of us.

Depending on the circumstances, that meant moving somebody to another crew, or laying them off.

Those were never decisions I made lightly. A paycheck matters. A person’s safety and dignity matter. And any personnel decision still has to respect the rules, the contracts, and whoever holds the actual authority.

But at least nobody could pretend the expectations had never been discussed.

We’d started with an agreement. We could go back to it.

And when the working relationship wasn’t working, we could recognize that clear-eyed, without turning the person into a villain.

WIIFM Isn’t an Excuse to Be Selfish

I can already hear the objection coming.

“If everyone’s asking what’s in it for me, doesn’t that mean everyone’s just selfish?”

No. That’s too small a read on it.

What’s in it for me might mean I get paid fairly. It might mean I can trust the person next to me. It might mean I go home safe at the end of the shift. Or it might mean I feel a little better about the world because I got to help somebody who needed it.

That last one matters to me more than the rest.

I don’t need every kindness to come back to me in the form of a transaction.

The danger shows up when somebody learns about WIIFM or Reciprocity and decides to use it as a lever, to work people into doing something they wouldn’t otherwise choose.

That’s where understanding influence tips over into manipulation.

It’s the same tightrope I talked about the other day.

Am I trying to help this person succeed, or am I just trying to get what I want out of them?

As a foreman, WIIFM made me better at two things at once: supporting the people on my crew, and holding them accountable.

I could acknowledge what they wanted. Be clear about what I needed. And ask them to take part in fixing whatever broke.

And sometimes, when our interests and working habits simply didn’t fit, I could let the relationship end without pretending that meant somebody had to be the bad guy.

You don’t have to keep every relationship alive forever to have handled it fairly.

The Foreman’s Job Goes Both Ways

Here’s the catch I want to leave you with.

If I tell a journeyman his job is to make mine easier, then mine is to make it easier for him to succeed.

I can’t expect him to own a project if I haven’t given him the tools, the information, the materials, and the decisions to carry it.

I can’t demand a safe job and then quietly pressure him into shortcuts.

I can’t tell him there’s no bullying on this crew and then be the biggest bully in the room.

An agreement only works if it runs in both directions.

And that’s what made this more than a clever speech I’d memorized.

It was a standing reminder of what both sides were actually there for.

We didn’t all have the same reasons for coming to work. Most of us didn’t.

But our different reasons could still line up behind a shared result.

That’s what WIIFM became for me.

Not a way to exploit somebody’s self-interest.

A way to find the common ground where everybody’s honest interests could actually meet.

Good leadership isn’t just getting people to give you what you need. It’s making sure they have what they need to give their best.

That’s the lesson my journeyman handed me when he told me my name was T.I.M.

⚔️ The Dojo Drill: Make the Agreement Before the Argument

Think of one working relationship where the expectations keep getting crossed.

Before you accuse the other person of not caring, try three questions.

1. What’s in it for them?

What are they genuinely trying to get from this arrangement? Money, safety, competence, respect, opportunity, belonging?

Don’t assume their answer is the same as yours.

And more importantly, have you shown them that what matters to them also matters to you?

2. What do you need from them?

Can you state the expectations plainly enough that both of you know what following through actually looks like?

3. What do you owe them in return?

What information, support, respect, or accountability do you have to provide for this to be a fair deal?

Have the conversation while the relationship is still working, not only after somebody’s already angry.

Because the best time to agree on how you’ll work together is before you have to argue about what went wrong.

And one last thing.

When you give someone a gift, give them a gift. Don’t dress a bribe up as generosity.

That distinction is part of what makes influence useful.

And it’s what keeps it honest.

📚 From the Leader’s Library

​Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion — Robert Cialdini​

Why?

What if some of the decisions you believe you’re making freely are being influenced by things you don’t even notice?

In Influence, Robert Cialdini explores the psychological principles that shape why people say yes, whom they trust, and how they make decisions—sometimes without consciously recognizing what’s influencing them.

I’m not recommending this book so you can learn to manipulate people.

I’m recommending it so you can recognize when someone might be manipulating you.

Whether it’s advertising, sales, social media, politics, or everyday relationships, understanding what motivates people helps you recognize the invisible pressures behind your decisions.

And it can help you communicate more effectively, honestly, and respectfully with others.

The goal isn’t to become better at controlling people. It’s to become harder to manipulate—and more deliberate about the choices you make.

Charles Doublet

Helping young men to become warriors, leaders, and teachers. Showing them how to overcome fear, bullies, and life's challenges so they can live the life they were meant to live, for more, check out https://CharlesDoublet.com/

Read more from Charles Doublet
Illustration of a thoughtful man examining seven wooden signs labeled reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, liking, authority, scarcity, and unity.

The Day I Started Seeing the Strings How studying marketing taught me to recognize influence without becoming cynical about people. I didn’t start studying marketing because I wanted to understand human nature. I started because I was trying to help Amy to build her service business. She had spent years getting genuinely good at her craft. The way she cared about her work, the care she put into it, was something I admired and wanted to support. But being excellent at the work and building a...

Illustration of an electrician working with thick electrical cables in an industrial junction box beside a headline about leading without being the captain.

How to Turn the Ship Around When You’re Not the Captain Sometimes the smartest way to lead is to let somebody else make the decision. There’s an old saying I picked up during my years in construction. "It’s better to ask forgiveness than permission." There’s some wisdom in that. If you spend your whole working life waiting to be told what to do, you’ll never develop much initiative. Somebody has to be willing to move before the memo arrives. But I learned another lesson later, and it...

Martial artist reflecting in a quiet dojo on the difference between reckless intensity and better judgment.

How I Stopped Being Stupid And why avoiding stupid decisions might save more than your pride. I once spent a couple of days in intensive care because I thought going harder and faster was the answer to a problem. It wasn’t. And it took a ruptured spleen to teach me that. But I’m getting ahead of myself. The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by Carlo Cippola There’s a little book by Carlo M. Cipolla called The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity. It’s funny. Sarcastic. Written with the kind of mock...