Are You Honking at a Car With Nobody Driving It?What two Waymos, one impatient driver, and the trolley problem can teach us about our own programming. Have you ever watched somebody do something so ridiculous that you couldn’t help laughing? And then, a little later, realized you might do exactly the same thing? That happened to me the other day. I was driving home from Alana’s, heading east on Venice Boulevard, when I stopped at the light at Centinela. There were two Waymos traveling south on Centinela, side by side. One in the left lane. One in the right lane. Both of them positioned to go straight through the intersection. And both of them were stopped. Now, here’s what caught my attention. They had a green light. I actually looked again, a second time, just to be sure. Yep. Green. But neither car was moving. There was also a car coming from the opposite direction, waiting to make a left turn across their path. I wondered if the Waymo in the left lane was holding back because that oncoming car might turn in front of it. That would make sense to me. Better to wait a few seconds than to risk somebody swinging across your nose. But what about the Waymo in the right lane? Why was it stopped too? Were the two Waymos somehow "talking" to each other about the intersection? Was the right-lane car detecting something I couldn’t see? Or was it working through its own decision based on information I’d never have access to? I had no idea. Eventually, the Waymo in the left lane went through. The one in the right lane stayed put. And then the SUV behind it started honking. HONK! HONK! At a car with nobody behind the wheel. I started laughing. I couldn’t help it. What was that driver expecting, exactly? Was the Waymo going to get embarrassed? Was some invisible driver going to look up from his phone and say, “Oh, shit, sorry buddy!”? Was the computer going to think, “This guy’s getting pissed, I better get moving”? A moment later, the Waymo moved. I don’t know whether the horn made any difference. And if I’m being honest, that’s part of what made it funny. Somebody laying on the horn at a machine, and me having no idea whether the machine even registered being yelled at. But while I was sitting there laughing, a quieter thought caught up with me. How many times have I been the guy honking at an "empty" driver’s seat? And more to the point — how many times have you? Which Driver Are You?Look at that intersection again. There were several different people in it, and every one of them was living a completely different version of the same ten seconds. I wonder which one sounds most like many of us. Maybe we’re the Waymo in the left lane. You see a possible danger up ahead. You don’t know if the other person is about to do something stupid, so you hold back. You’d rather be cautious than make a costly mistake. That can be a genuinely smart response. But have you ever been so worried about what might happen that you stopped moving even when the way forward was actually clear? Have you ever stalled on a decision because you wanted more certainty than the situation could ever give you? Maybe we’re the Waymo in the right lane. Everybody around you seems ready to go, but you’re still sitting there. Maybe you’ve noticed something no one else has. Maybe you’re following a rule that made perfect sense when it was written. Or maybe you’re waiting for conditions that will never be perfect. Are you making a deliberate choice, or just running the program you’ve always run? Or maybe we’re the SUV driver. Somebody’s in your way. You’ve got somewhere to be. As far as you’re concerned, there’s no good reason for the delay. So you do what you’ve always done. You honk. How often do you get frustrated because somebody isn’t doing what you think they should do? At work. In traffic. At home. On the mat. Maybe we’re me, sitting at the intersection, laughing at everybody else. I could see the green lights. I could see the cars. I could make some pretty reasonable guesses about what was going on. But I didn’t know what either Waymo was detecting, how its system was weighing the intersection, or whether the two cars were sharing information. I didn’t know what the "driver" behind it was thinking. I was just an observer. An observer with an opinion. Sound familiar? Here’s the thing about being the observer. It’s the position that feels the most like it has the whole picture. I was sitting there with a clear view of the whole intersection, watching everybody make what looked like obvious mistakes. And I still didn’t actually know why any of them did what they did. We’re All Running Some Kind of ProgrammingThis week, we’re walking through Robert Cialdini’s book Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. One of the ideas I keep coming back to is how much of our behavior runs on mental shortcuts. We learn patterns. We build habits. We wire certain signals to certain responses.
These shortcuts make life livable. If you had to consciously evaluate every single decision in your day, you’d never get out of the driveway. Cialdini shows how cues around authority, reciprocity, social proof, scarcity, and the rest shape our behavior. Sometimes they steer us toward good calls. Sometimes they steer us straight into a wall. And sometimes people deliberately pull those levers to move us in a direction that serves them. But the first step in recognizing influence isn’t learning how to work other people. It’s recognizing how easily we get worked on. A shortcut that usually works isn’t guaranteed to work in every situation. And the older I get, the more I notice the moments where mine stop serving me.
That’s your programming, doing its job. What If the Programming Is Trying to Keep Everybody Safe?Watching those two Waymos got me thinking about something else. We like to imagine that if we can just program a machine correctly, it’ll always make the right call. But what’s the right call, exactly? And right for whom? There’s a famous thought experiment called the trolley problem. Imagine a runaway trolley barreling toward five people who can’t get out of the way. You’re standing next to a lever. If you pull it, the trolley switches to a side track. But there’s one person on that track. If you do nothing, five people die. If you pull the lever, one person dies. What do you do? Before you answer, sit with this part. There is no version of the story where everybody walks away. You’re not choosing between good and bad. You’re choosing between two terrible things, and the best you can do is pick which terrible thing you can live with. Some people focus on the numbers. Others focus on the moral difference between causing harm directly and merely allowing harm to happen. Neither answer is childish. And that’s the uncomfortable point. A lot of life doesn’t hand you good versus bad. It hands you bad versus worse. And what looks like “worse” to you might look completely different to the person standing in a different spot. Now imagine trying to program a computer to make that call. Whose values do you load in? Yours? Mine? The engineers’? The passengers’? The people standing on the tracks? And what happens when those values disagree? Safe for Whom?Now bring that question back to the self-driving car. We all want these things to be safe. Of course we do. But safe for whom? The people inside? Pedestrians? Cyclists? The other drivers? Ideally, everybody. And most of the time, the right move is to keep the dangerous situation from developing in the first place. But real roads don’t cooperate. People make mistakes. Conditions change. Information is always incomplete. And sometimes the risks compete with each other. A car approaches an intersection with a green light. Another car looks ready to turn across its path. Does it proceed on right of way, or hold back because the other driver might mess up? What if holding back creates a different problem? What if a driver behind gets impatient and makes a dangerous move of their own? What if the car has picked up a pedestrian that nobody else can see? I’m not claiming that’s what happened with either Waymo I watched. I don’t know. And a self-driving car isn’t literally solving the trolley problem every time it reaches a light. That would be a silly way to describe it. But the thought experiment does surface something real. Even a system built around safety has to juggle conflicting goods, incomplete information, and uncertainty. So do you. When you make a decision, whose safety, comfort, success, or happiness are you actually prioritizing? Yours? Your family’s? Your crew’s? Your customers’? And have you ever made what felt like the responsible choice, only to find out it created a problem for somebody else? That doesn’t necessarily mean you chose wrong. Sometimes there is no clean choice to make. But it is a reason to stop assuming your view of the intersection is the only one in play. Are We Even Looking at the Same Information?You remember my question about whether the two Waymos were talking to each other. I don’t know that they were. They could have been making independent calls. They could have been responding to two different things. The fact that both stopped doesn’t prove they were in contact. But the question is worth sitting with for a different reason. Because it made me think about how often human beings make decisions without ever sharing the information sitting behind them. Picture two people working together. One sees a problem and stops. The other doesn’t know why. From the second person’s view, the first looks indecisive, uncooperative, or slow. But what if the first person knows something important? Now flip it. What if the first person is working off outdated information, following a rule that no longer applies? How would either of them know, unless one of them actually said something? I saw versions of this my entire career in electrical construction. Competent people, all aiming at the same goal, still creating problems for each other because they were running on different assumptions. One guy thinks the work’s ready to go. Another knows the material hasn’t arrived. One guy thinks we push forward. Another sees a safety issue. One guy assumes everybody understands the plan. Nobody’s checked. The problem usually isn’t that anybody’s stupid. It’s that they’re working from different information. So maybe there’s a useful habit we can practice: Before deciding somebody else is wrong, ask one more question. Not because we have to agree with them. Because there may be something important we haven’t seen. The Most Dangerous Programming Might Be Your OwnHere’s the part of this that matters most to me. I don’t want to become somebody who automatically rejects authority, or automatically bows to it. I don’t want to follow a crowd just because it’s a crowd. But I also don’t want to refuse a good idea just because it got popular. I don’t want to get so cautious that I never move. Or so impatient that I roll right past real danger. And I certainly don’t want to get so convinced of my own read on things that I stop checking it. Because there’s a trap hiding in learning about influence. You start noticing the patterns in everybody else. You see when someone’s deferring to authority, when someone’s jumping at scarcity, when someone’s just following the herd. And it’s tempting to feel a little superior about it. Look at all these people running on autopilot. But what about you? What about me? Recognizing somebody else’s programming doesn’t mean you’ve escaped your own. Sometimes you’re the cautious Waymo. Sometimes you’re the impatient SUV driver. Sometimes you’re the observer laughing at the whole thing. And sometimes you’re the oncoming driver, making a decision that quietly changes what every other person at that intersection is allowed to do. None of those spots automatically makes you right or wrong. The question is whether you have any idea which one you’re standing in. ⚔️ Your Daily Dojo DrillReplay a recent disagreement, or a frustrating moment, or a decision you’ve been putting off. It could be at work, with your partner, with a friend, in traffic, anywhere. Now picture that situation as the intersection. 1. Were you the cautious Waymo? Did you see a genuine risk, or were you holding back because you couldn’t stand the uncertainty? 2. Were you the stationary Waymo? Were you acting on information no one else had, or following an old rule without asking if it still fit? 3. Were you the impatient SUV driver? Were you frustrated because someone wasn’t doing what you expected, without understanding why they weren’t? 4. Were you the observer? Were you judging everyone else’s decisions while ignoring everything you didn’t actually know? 5. Or were you the oncoming driver? Was there something you were doing, or about to do, that changed the risks and choices facing everybody around you? Then one more question. Was there actually a clean, good decision available to anyone — or was everybody just trying to pick the least harmful option they could live with? Don’t turn every small moment into a philosophy seminar. Sometimes the light goes green and you just drive. But when something feels wrong, or confusing, or unfair, it’s worth asking whether you’re responding to the situation that’s actually in front of you. Or whether you’re still running a program that made sense somewhere else, at some earlier time. Because sometimes you’re the Waymo. Sometimes you’re the guy honking. And sometimes you’re just one more person at the intersection, doing your best to figure out what the hell everybody else is doing. 📚 From the Leader’s LibraryInfluence: The Psychology of Persuasion — Robert Cialdini Why? What if some of the decisions you believe you’re making freely are being influenced by things you don’t even notice? In Influence, Robert Cialdini explores the psychological principles that shape why people say yes, whom they trust, and how they make decisions—sometimes without consciously recognizing what’s influencing them. I’m not recommending this book so you can learn to manipulate people. I’m recommending it so you can recognize when someone might be manipulating you. Whether it’s advertising, sales, social media, politics, or everyday relationships, understanding what motivates people helps you recognize the invisible pressures behind your decisions. And it can help you communicate more effectively, honestly, and respectfully with others. The goal isn’t to become better at controlling people. It’s to become harder to manipulate—and more deliberate about the choices you make. |
Helping young men to become warriors, leaders, and teachers. Showing them how to overcome fear, bullies, and life's challenges so they can live the life they were meant to live, for more, check out https://CharlesDoublet.com/
The Question Every Person on My Crew Was Asking How studying marketing taught me to become a better foreman, and made it easier to keep good people or let the wrong fit go. I didn’t study marketing to become a better foreman. I was trying to help my wife, Amy build her somatic therapy business. So I started learning the business side of things, the part nobody hands you along with your tools when you get good at your trade. Then I ran across five letters that changed the way I dealt with...
The Day I Started Seeing the Strings How studying marketing taught me to recognize influence without becoming cynical about people. I didn’t start studying marketing because I wanted to understand human nature. I started because I was trying to help Amy to build her service business. She had spent years getting genuinely good at her craft. The way she cared about her work, the care she put into it, was something I admired and wanted to support. But being excellent at the work and building a...
How to Turn the Ship Around When You’re Not the Captain Sometimes the smartest way to lead is to let somebody else make the decision. There’s an old saying I picked up during my years in construction. "It’s better to ask forgiveness than permission." There’s some wisdom in that. If you spend your whole working life waiting to be told what to do, you’ll never develop much initiative. Somebody has to be willing to move before the memo arrives. But I learned another lesson later, and it...